Simple Simon Bakery

Custom Specialty Cakes

Baked fresh from scratch for birthdays, graduations, religious milestones, and every celebration in between.

Order a Cake

The Process

How It Works

1
Choose Your Occasion
Browse by occasion below and pick the cake style that fits your celebration.
2
Customize Your Cake
Select your size, flavor, icing, and share any special details or design ideas.
3
Place Your Order
Order online and choose in-store pickup or local delivery at checkout.
4
Fresh Baked for You
Your custom cake is baked fresh from scratch and ready on your chosen date.

Browse by Occasion

What Are You Celebrating?

Every cake is made to order. Choose an occasion to get started.

🎂
Birthday

Make their birthday unforgettable with a cake designed just for them.

Order Now
✝️
Religious

Baptisms, First Communions, Confirmations — beautifully crafted for your milestone.

Order Now
🎓
Graduation

Celebrate the hard work and the big achievement with a custom grad cake.

Order Now
🥂
Anniversary

Weddings, years of service, retirement — every milestone deserves a memorable cake.

Order Now

Cake Style

Choose Your Cake Style

Not sure which size? Both styles are fully customizable.

Round Cake

Two layers with filling in between — the classic celebration cake, baked fresh from scratch.

Available in 6″, 7″, 8″, 9″, 10″, 12″
Customize Round Cake
Sheet Cake

Single layer, generously iced — perfect for larger gatherings, office parties, and school events.

Quarter Sheet, Half Sheet, Full Sheet
Customize Sheet Cake